Monday, October 26, 2015

XTRA 471

This post is something of a work in progress. This is one of the set of photos that inspired my "Williams Creek" bridge scene. It's been something of an ongoing project to identify each of the cars in this train with the idea of modeling them.
I've managed to ID most of them - but believe I may have misidentified the boxcar in the second photo partially obscured by the bush. At first look I saw the Roman style "L &" (all that's readable in the photo, though there is clearly another single letter after the "&") and figured this might be an Louisville & Nashville car, perhaps one of the L&N's rebuilt cars with "reverse" Murphy ends. This seemed entirely logical. L&N didn't have a huge boxcar fleet, but it was a fairly substantial one, and entirely likely to show up in a wayfreight in south-central New England.
But closer examination shows the car has a flat end and a pronounced seam at the top of the end creating the appearance of a triangle on the top of the end. I couldn't identify a class of L&N boxcars that looked like the rest of the car with that style end. One group of cars with this end were the 1932 ARA boxcars. But which of those would have "L &" as the reporting marks.
The true freight car experts already have the answer of course. And, after doing a little more digging this weekend I'm now of the opinion this is a much more rare (considering sheer numbers) Louisiana & Arkansas 1932 ARA boxcar. As built these cars had a block, almost Gothic style lettering with the roadname spelled out above the reporting marks.
This one doesn't have the roadname and the lettering is clearly Roman. Which means this is the second scheme these cars wore, with the "L&A" and car number to the left of the door and a Kansas City Southern herald to the right of the door. 
I know Atlas makes a 1932 ARA boxcar - and even made one in this scheme. 
Guess who can't find one of those anywhere??

3 comments:

  1. I'm doing something similar. I have a limited number of photos of operations in North Tonawanda NY, the town I'm modelling. However, I'm trying to model the cars I see in the photos. I'm finding it's a challenge, but it's satisfying and fun.

    Good luck in year search for the L&A boxcar!
    -Hunter

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Marty,

    I don't think that the L&A car is a 1932 ARA box car. It doesn't have a tabbed side sill. I have this photo, too, and tried my best to determine the provenance of the car, but came up empty looking at my L&A and KCS freight car photos. I am stumped, but I'll keep digging...

    Cheers,
    Ted Culotta

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ted… of course I managed to finally locate the Atlas 1932 L&A car BEFORE seeing your comment.
      This is rapidly degenerating into a real mystery….
      Perhaps it's neither "L&N" or "L&A"…. but that's pretty clearly an "L" - at least I think it is….
      So what else starts with an "L" - "LNE," "LV"….
      Let me know if you come up with something!
      Marty

      Delete